Help / feedback


  • Aoe damage order 2

    Suppose i have Luminous Seedling and two Brilliant Thorn`s on my field. All of them have one wound token. My opponent uses Nature's Wrath. Who decides which creatures are taking damage first?

  • targeting 4

    So my friend and I were playing a game, and he was using a celestial knight, 3 spectral assassin's, and a shepherd of lost souls to attack my phoenixborn. I used my Beast Tamer's effect to remove 1 basic die and lower the attacking units attack by 1. He proceeded to play angelic rescue on his celestial knight to cancel the effect of my tamer. He said that my beast tamers effect targets, however the beast tamers card text doesn't specifically say "target".

    So would angelic rescue work in this situation?

  • Chants and Summons 5

    Two questions I encountered:
    If I have the Summon Dread Wraith ready spell Focused 2 and all the spells are exhausted, can I still use that focused ability to remove an exhaustion token from a dread wraith?
    I think I know the answer to this, but if I have a Chant of Protection with tokens on it on my spell board can does it take hits for my Pheonixborn when I use the ceremonial power dice ability to retrieve an ally from my discard pile?

  • Deal damage Events 6

    Night Shade Swallow had a rewording such that it needs to do at least 1 damage to trigger its ability, so i wondered if the same is true for other units (found nothing in the faq).
    Say my spectral assassin has Regress attached to it and attacks a phoenixborn.
    Do i get to draw a card still ?

    My guess is that it i do, but it does not feel very consistent.

  • Living Doll Ability Timing 3

    Hello all!
    I just got my core set recently from a local buy/trade/sell group and decided to give Ashes a shot. The game is very good and my friends and I are quickly addicted!

    In our recent games we encounter a situation and I would like to figure this out. Jessa Nani's Living Doll will deal damage or "transfer" damage to another unit or opposing Phoenixborn, but does that ability triggers even when Living Doll blocks / receives damage and dies? Or it only triggers provided that Living Doll is still on the battlefield after the damage resolves?

    My playgroup's logic is similar to Magic in which units who are dead will not trigger this kind of static / passive / trigger condition abilities.

    Let me know what you guys think!

  • Amplify 3

    If you place charm dice on a unit with Amplify do they stay there until that unit is dead or is it just for the round?

  • Battle Advantage 3

    How does Battle Advantage work? I know that a unit, such as Seaside Raven, inflict their damage before other units without. When does this come into play? How is this practically used in a game?

  • Removing units from the game 2

    When it's written on a card like Law Of Banishment "...remove that conjuration from the game...", do they mean every copy of that conjuration or only the destroyed one? And is it the same for allies like for Silver snake?

  • Recovery - new player 2

    Probably a dumb question, but I am new to the game. When a unit has recovery and takes enough damage to destroy it, how does it recover the life if it is removed for battlefield already. Recovery occurs at the end of a round, correct?

  • Majestic Titan vs Holy Knight, also Seeds of Aggression 7

    Directly under the preview there was a discussion if Majestic Titan can interact with Holy knight.
    Short Version :
    You can Force Holy knight to deal its damage to other Units, but Holy Knight can not be chosen to recieve the damage.
    Also Seeds of Aggression can deal Damage to Holy Knight.
    EDIT : The card does say 'target' which i overread. Can't use Seeds of aggression on an unexhausted Holy Knight.

    Why ? Because of the way affecting something is described in the FAQ and the way things were handled up till now, namely that event chains don't matter. (If A causes B and B causes C, the game does not rule that A causes C).
    Sources for this are further below.

    How does this affect Majestic Titan and Holy Knight ?
    1. If the Titan hits the Holy Knight the event for Befuddling Blow does definitely trigger. The Question is if Holy Knight is immune to the effect.
    Obviously the 'Befuddling Blow' is used by an opponent in the example, so the only thing that could go wrong is that it does not qualify as 'affecting'.
    The relevant part in the FAQ says

    [...] A card does not affect another card if an effect chooses it, or if it targets another card with an attack.

    Now it is not exactly clear what 'it' references, so we rewrite the statement to make talking about it a little easier.
    It either means :

    [...] A card A does not affect another card B if an effect chooses A, or if A targets another card with an attack.


    [...] A card A does not affect another card B if an effect chooses B, or if B targets another card with an attack.

    The first statement is obvious. If such things needed explanation the rule book would need 10x times more text.
    (The seconds statement also seems like it could have been written in order to future proof for Seeds of aggression which just ended up not formally causing an attack.)
    But now Befuddling Blow does not (formally) affect Holy Knight and the effect has to be evaluated.

    2. What if Holy Knight is on the damage receiving side of befuddling blow.
    It would be explicitly allowed to chose (but not target) the Holy Knight by the FAQ.
    However Befuddling Blow targets the damage receiving Unit so Holy Knight would be affected, hence is immune.
    Note that the other case worked because there the Holy Knight was chosen (by the phrase '[...] that Unit [...]') and not targeted.

    Edit (all wrong, it does read target) : For Comparions : <wrong>The Card Seed Of Aggression choses both its 'targets'/chosen Units, so Holy Knight can be affected by it. This is where the 'Chain of Events' stuff is relevant.
    Yes you use a spell to cause a Unit to deal damage to Holy Knight, but that does not imply that the damage the Unit deals is caused by a spell an Opponent uses (example further below).
    Since Holy Knight is not immune to being dealt damage by a Unit, the effect**

    Conclusion : You can Force Holy knight to deal its damage to other Units, but Holy Knight can not be chosen to receive the damage. Edit : Also Seed of Aggression can not be used on an unexhausted (opposing) Holy Knight.

    The FAQ :

    A card affects another card or player if it attaches, destroys, removes from the game, targets with an effect, deals damage from an effect, places tokens, removes tokens, moves tokens onto or from another card, cancels it, modifies an ability, or modifies base stats of a unit. A card does not affect another card if an effect chooses it, or if it targets another card with an attack.

    Rules up till now :
    It is also established, that we do not have to keep track of what causes what.
    The main example for this comes from this thread by the User tony78000#2u2d :

    Attack with snake --> damage on illusion unit --> trigger illusion ability --> destruction of illusion unit

    The scenario with the bat attacking phoenixborn would be like this :
    Attack with bat --> activate bat swarm ability --> damage on illusion unit.

    Why would illusion trigger in the 2nd case while consume does not trigger in the 1st case ? Both wording contains "as a result of", and if we take your logic on bat case, the destruction of the unit in the 1st case is also due to the attack of the snake (that you control), hence triggering Consume. However, it has been officially ruled that Consume does not trigger in this case. By analogy, it seems legit to say that the illusion ability won't trigger in the 2nd case.

    This is the closest we can ever hope to come to logical proof without direct developer ruling.